Three deejays made the cut for Best Reggae Album at the 69th Grammy Awards. Scroll through social media since the November 16 announcement, though, and you’d think dancehall had been shut out completely.
Fans and industry figures have been loudly questioning why albums from Vybz Kartel, Beenie Man, Capleton, Masicka and Alkaline didn’t land a nomination.
The missing titles include Kartel’s God and Time, Beenie Man’s Eminence, Capleton’s Heights of Fire, Masicka’s Forever Reign and Alkaline’s NPT. Some have even suggested the Recording Academy has a bias against dancehall artistes.
The actual nominees are Buju Banton’s Too Too Bad, Protoje’s The Art of Acceptance, Runkus with Supernova, Chronixx with Exile, Ziggy Marley’s Brightside and Shaggy’s Lottery.
That lineup has reopened an old argument: does dancehall need a Grammy category of its own?
Some want a fully separate dancehall award, while others say renaming the category Best Reggae/Dancehall Album would do the job. Canada has already gone that route.
A few months ago the JUNO Awards announced its Reggae Recording of the Year would become Reggae/Dancehall Recording of the Year for 2027.

Entertainment attorney Lloyd Stanbury isn’t interested in a name change. “Dancehall music has earned and deserves its own standalone category in the Grammys,” he told the Jamaica Observer.
He argues the genre “has evolved and grown to establish itself globally as yet another distinct music genre coming out of Jamaica.”
Veteran producer and manager Ralston Barrett, who has more than 30 years in the business, called the nominations “a slap in the face to dancehall music.”
He counts Buju as the only nominee squarely in the dancehall camp. He was hoping to see Masicka, Kartel, Alkaline and Capleton in the mix.
Barrett admits the numbers aren’t there yet. The reggae category, created in 1985, was reportedly close to being cut a few years ago over low submissions, and entries only climbed to 119 this year from 73 last year. “A category of our own would give artistes even more reason to submit,” he said.
Ce’Cile, an artiste, producer and Recording Academy member, takes a blunter view. “They [Grammys] are not obligated to do anything,” she said, pointing out that plenty of genres still have no category at all.

She also turned the question back on Jamaica: “How many of us within the industry are voting members? We don’t even support our local award shows.”
Cristy Barber, a Grammy-nominated producer and former chair of the Grammy reggae committee, pushed back on the idea that dancehall was ignored.
She pointed to Buju, Shaggy and Runkus as deejays, saying “Hard-core, crossover, however you see it, they are still dancehall.” In her view, the Academy already treats the category as covering both reggae and dancehall.
History backs her up to a point, with Shabba Ranks, Beenie Man, Sean Paul, Buju Banton and Shaggy all having won the reggae Grammy.
Stanbury and Barrett both say the real lever is getting more Jamaican creatives into the Academy as voting members, and that push is only just getting started.
